Greens warn our health data is at risk under Minns Labor government plan
The Greens NSW spokesperson for Health Dr Amanda Cohn has sounded the alarm on NSW Government’s plan to introduce AI scribes into NSW Health services, despite ongoing cybersecurity failures.
Dr Cohn led a motion that passed the upper house, calling on the NSW Government to urgently invest in fixing known cybersecurity vulnerabilities at NSW Health before further expansion of the use of AI, and to create jobs for clinical support officers to help health professionals with administrative tasks instead of outsourcing to AI.
Dr Cohn said in Parliament: “AI in health care is expanding in an utterly rampant and unchecked manner, well ahead of the government regulation that is needed to keep up with it.”
The Greens-led motion follows news earlier this month of a major cybersecurity incident at NSW Health, raising serious questions about whether the Minns Labor Government has acted on warnings about the health system's cybersecurity failures.
Independent findings from the NSW Audit Office, published in December 2025, warned that NSW Health was not effectively managing cybersecurity risks to clinical systems and that Local Health Districts were inadequately prepared to respond to cyber incidents.
The report found that three of the four audited Local Health Districts did not have a cybersecurity plan, four out of four had cybersecurity incident response plans that were not fit for purpose, and only two of the four had conducted desktop exercises to test their incident response plans.
The Audit Office’s report warned: ‘This exposes the risk that a preventable cyber security incident could disrupt access to healthcare services and compromise the security of sensitive patient information.’
NSW Health accepted all six recommendations in the Audit Office report.
“Despite these known risks, the Minns Labor government is spending nearly 39 million dollars on AI scribes at NSW Health, essentially inviting AI into its data and exposing our health records to even more risk.”
“As a former GP I know the types of sensitive information in people’s medical records. For many people, this is information they wouldn’t want members of their own family to see, let alone their employer or the general public. By inviting AI into medical records when appropriate regulation hasn’t caught up, we aren’t only risking that this information leaks, but that records themselves can be altered and inaccurate, posing real risk to our health.”
In September, after an OpenAI agent infiltrated Medicare websites to access non-public files, and did not notify the Government until almost three months after the incident, Dr Cohn asked the Health Minister: “How can the privacy of our medical records be assured when security is so flagrantly disregarded by AI companies?” The response from Courtney Houssous, the Minister representing the Minister for Health was that “We have a robust system in place to protect people's data.”
Dr Cohn said reassurances from the Minns Labor government were unconvincing given the Auditor General’s independent report and ongoing cybersecurity attacks.